* Thursday Update
(o+) Anything to Discredit the Interim Government: Overreaction Heaped on Overreaction ... and How to Discredit Yourself
On Tuesday the Fiji Sun ran an article on a claim by "an unnamed policeman" that the (Police Christian crusade against crime) was being imposed on Indo-Fijian police officers, and that "officers who had converted to the New Methodist Church, which had been conducting most of the crusades, have been getting promotions."
By Wednesday, all the press, the national TV, and two anti-Interim Government NGOs (the Fiji Womens Crisis Centre and the Movement for Democracy in Fiji) had rolled up their sleeves and were swinging wildly at Police Commissioner Commodore Esala Teleni (photograph) who, admittedly, didn't help his case by having privately (sic!) lambasted Indo-Fijian officers for disloyalty in speaking to the media, and for their negative comments about the crusade. He is said to have warned the officers to support him or leave the force. The media and NGOs called him a racist and some called for his resignation.
But it now transpires no senior Indo-Fijian officer spoke to the media and none has been coerced to support the crusade. They do, however, claim to know who was "the real voice behind the article". One officer said "We believe it is the different denominations of the Christian faith within the police who are unhappy with the crusade, or at least which denomination is heading it. At times", he said, "I have gone to the crusades on my own accord, and have never been told to convert as some media have reported". He said they had "nothing against the police chief for speaking to us the way he did because he has strong beliefs about his faith ... As for the crusade, we support it, it brings discipline into the force and we have never been forced to attend any of the crusades.” (Fiji Live)
Too late. Such was the "crisis" created by the media that Interim Defence Minister Ratu Epeli Ganilau and PM Bainimarama took precious time out to speak with Teleni, and later the media. Both supported Teleni.
By Thursday Shaista Shameen (FHRC), Mahendra Chaudhry (FLP), Mike Beddoes and Akuila Yabaki (CCF) thought the need for further comment when, other than insistence on personal and religious freedom, they may have been better to have said nothing.
There is no question that Teleni's outburst did him no credit (and no question that personal and religious freedoms must be protected) but the media must also accept responsibility. They started the fire, fanned and whipped up the flames over what would appear to be a relatively minor incident -- and much of what they reported would seem to be incorrect.
To play a responsible role in a Fiji where its opponents use every opportunity to discredit the Interim Government, the media must at least check its sources -- the original sources, not those of an "unnamed" someone printed by another newspaper -- and do what it can to douse unnecessary heat. Cool heads, not merry arsonists, are needed in the months ahead.
P.S. Friday. And it's not over yet. Overreaction builds on overreaction. FijiLive reports that the military is conducting a "headhunt" to identify the officers who spoke to the press. "Interim Prime Minister Commodore Voreqe Bainimarama has also confirmed advising Teleni, his former military second-in-command, to carry out the head hunt and rout them out of the Force."
(-) Pramod Rae, Gen.Sec. of the once important National Federation Party, has once again supported Laisenia Qarase. This time on his statement that all Forum countries should join Australia and New Zealand in imposing a travel ban on members, supporters and relatives of the military and Interim Government. [Other than as a token gesture of solidarity, bans by other Forum countries could weaken the Forum's influence, and backfire on Forum countries dependent on the Nadi air hub for their travel, should Fiji choose to retaliate. This blog agrees with the growing number of people who believe the travel bans have been counter-productive. At the very least they should be applied more selectively. Punishing children for the "sins"of their fathers is not the way to go.]
(o+) Anything to Discredit the Interim Government: Overreaction Heaped on Overreaction ... and How to Discredit Yourself
On Tuesday the Fiji Sun ran an article on a claim by "an unnamed policeman" that the (Police Christian crusade against crime) was being imposed on Indo-Fijian police officers, and that "officers who had converted to the New Methodist Church, which had been conducting most of the crusades, have been getting promotions."
By Wednesday, all the press, the national TV, and two anti-Interim Government NGOs (the Fiji Womens Crisis Centre and the Movement for Democracy in Fiji) had rolled up their sleeves and were swinging wildly at Police Commissioner Commodore Esala Teleni (photograph) who, admittedly, didn't help his case by having privately (sic!) lambasted Indo-Fijian officers for disloyalty in speaking to the media, and for their negative comments about the crusade. He is said to have warned the officers to support him or leave the force. The media and NGOs called him a racist and some called for his resignation.
But it now transpires no senior Indo-Fijian officer spoke to the media and none has been coerced to support the crusade. They do, however, claim to know who was "the real voice behind the article". One officer said "We believe it is the different denominations of the Christian faith within the police who are unhappy with the crusade, or at least which denomination is heading it. At times", he said, "I have gone to the crusades on my own accord, and have never been told to convert as some media have reported". He said they had "nothing against the police chief for speaking to us the way he did because he has strong beliefs about his faith ... As for the crusade, we support it, it brings discipline into the force and we have never been forced to attend any of the crusades.” (Fiji Live)
Too late. Such was the "crisis" created by the media that Interim Defence Minister Ratu Epeli Ganilau and PM Bainimarama took precious time out to speak with Teleni, and later the media. Both supported Teleni.
By Thursday Shaista Shameen (FHRC), Mahendra Chaudhry (FLP), Mike Beddoes and Akuila Yabaki (CCF) thought the need for further comment when, other than insistence on personal and religious freedom, they may have been better to have said nothing.
There is no question that Teleni's outburst did him no credit (and no question that personal and religious freedoms must be protected) but the media must also accept responsibility. They started the fire, fanned and whipped up the flames over what would appear to be a relatively minor incident -- and much of what they reported would seem to be incorrect.
To play a responsible role in a Fiji where its opponents use every opportunity to discredit the Interim Government, the media must at least check its sources -- the original sources, not those of an "unnamed" someone printed by another newspaper -- and do what it can to douse unnecessary heat. Cool heads, not merry arsonists, are needed in the months ahead.
P.S. Friday. And it's not over yet. Overreaction builds on overreaction. FijiLive reports that the military is conducting a "headhunt" to identify the officers who spoke to the press. "Interim Prime Minister Commodore Voreqe Bainimarama has also confirmed advising Teleni, his former military second-in-command, to carry out the head hunt and rout them out of the Force."
(-) Pramod Rae, Gen.Sec. of the once important National Federation Party, has once again supported Laisenia Qarase. This time on his statement that all Forum countries should join Australia and New Zealand in imposing a travel ban on members, supporters and relatives of the military and Interim Government. [Other than as a token gesture of solidarity, bans by other Forum countries could weaken the Forum's influence, and backfire on Forum countries dependent on the Nadi air hub for their travel, should Fiji choose to retaliate. This blog agrees with the growing number of people who believe the travel bans have been counter-productive. At the very least they should be applied more selectively. Punishing children for the "sins"of their fathers is not the way to go.]
2 comments:
There are several issues here:
- the Police Commissioner decides Christian crusades will benefit the force and community
- media run with a story complaining about the Christian crusades for the police, alleging forced attendance
- Teleni believes the media stories and attacks a senior group of officers selected based on their ethnic origin or religious beliefs
- Prime Minister & Defence Minister swallow the media story, smell disloyalty and commend the Police Commissioner for dealing swiftly and decisively with the problem of rogue elements who necessarily all belong to a particular ethnic or religious group
- Another source comes forward suggesting that this is an interdenominational biff with the non-Christians caught in the middle
Seems like everyone screwed up here ... and despite their constant railing against the media, Teleni, Bainimarama and Ganilau all believed and acted on the media version rather than enquiring within the force.
Teleni might have found the Fiji Live source himself and got that side of the story, had he stopped and listened before launching into racist rhetoric against what now seems to be the wrong crowd.
And don't try and blow off the accusation of racism: Teleni's speech was disgusting in both its tone and selection of audience. If he wanted to make a point about loyalty, procedure and dealing with the media, he should have made it to all his senior officers, regardless of ethnicity or creed.
Regardless, Teleni has introduced a very divisive factor with his promotion of these crusades within the force.
The bigger questions seem to have been missed:
- Why the police force is aligning itself with religious activities of a particular persuasion
- Why the PM is directing Teleni to investigate this matter. Any self-respecting Police Commissioner would have respectfully pointed out that the police do not take investigative directives from the Government of the day
- Why Teleni, Bainimarama, Ganilau and Shameem prefer the media account to their own internal intelligence ... and why they would support a misplaced and racist response based on said media account without any internal investigation.
Dearest Esteems,
We are Offering best Global Financial Service rendered to the general public with maximum satisfaction,maximum risk free. Do not miss this opportunity. Join the most trusted financial institution and secure a legitimate financial empowerment to add meaning to your life/business.
Contact Dr. James Eric Firm via
Email: fastloanoffer34@gmail.com
Whatsapp +918929509036
Best Regards,
Dr. James Eric.
Executive Investment
Consultant./Mediator/Facilitator
Post a Comment