Cogito, ergo sum. I think, therefore I am.
(René Descartes, mathematician and philosopher, 1599-1650).
NOTE our new bird, the whio, to the left of the heading.

Tuesday, 2 March 2021

The Inequity of standard traffic fines (pn695)

Yesterday evening's TV1 Highway Cops programme revealed something of the inequity of standard traffic fines which relates to the wider question of treating people the same or truly equally, a topic I've raised several  times before. Take two stories from the programme.  

In the first, a 25-something young man is  driving in his Ute with his two brothers. The Ute has had its odometer tampered with and has  no warrant of fitness. He  is fined $400.  Though he was obviously trying to dodge road user charges, the cop said they were not bad boys and he expected them to do the right thing by removing the switch and wiring that disabled the odometer.  

In the second, a Māori mother in Ōtaki with six children is also fined $400,  for driving without a valid licence. She will need to find another $600 or so to obtain a new licence,  a total of over $1000.   

Case 1, deliberate fraud and cheating. Deprived road transport of money.   Case 2, she probably couldn't afford the licence without depriving her household of an "essential." She cheated no one.  And both were treated equally?

Which raises the issue of standard fines which charge the same amount for an offence, irrespective of the circumstances of the offence and  irrespective of the income of the offender. 

Think of different offenders exceeding the speed limit by 12kph, one close to a school on a weekday at 3pm, another in a hailstorm, and another on a straight, open road on a moon-lit night. All are charged $80. Yet the offences close to a school and in a hailstorm would seem to warrant larger fines.

Think, also, of the likely income of  offenders.  The same fine for two people on vastly different incomes and responsibilities impacts very differently and  is grossly inequitable.  A fine of $80 would hardly affect me, but it could mean no school lunches for a mother with six children.

It is obviously impossible to fine tune every traffic fine to allow for circumstance and offender income, but I do think circumstance and income should be raised during police training and some further effort be made to compensate for income differences.

-- ACW

No comments:

Post a comment

All polite, reasoned, original comments welcomed. Please use your real name or a pseudonym by clicking on the down arrow next to Comment and then select Name/URL. You do not need to fill in URL. . Anonymous comments make discussion difficult..