Tales of Tonga and Minerva Reef

Directions from Nuku'alofa: Fonuafo'ou, North; Ono-i-Lau and Tovata-i-Ra, West; Minerva, SW.
Near confrontation.

The ownership of Minerva Reef has been an unresolved issue between Fiji and Tonga for quite a while but recently heightened sensitivities about where — exactly— the marine boundary lies between the two countries have allowed the issue to resurface —an apt term because the reef is submerged at high tide— at an unfortunate time and in an unfortunate way.

I have no special knowledge on the issue and have no intention of taking sides, except to say the reef seems closer to 'Ata in Tonga than Ono-i-Lau and Tovata-i-Ra in Fiji. (see map.)  I have lived and worked in both countries, and have warm feelings towards them.   But I'll make one observation and point to an historic precedent for Tonga's propensity for staking its territorial claims. 

The Tongan island group is perched at the edge of the Pacific plate and is comprised of a parallel chain on low coral and raised coral islands to the east ('Eua, Tongatapu and the Ha'apai and Vava'u groups) and small, steep volcanic islands to the west (from uninhabited 'Ata in the south to Niuafo'ou in the north). Submarine volcanic activity is frequent, and sometimes large quantities of ash are pushed to the surface to form temporary islands.  One such is Fonuafo'ou (new land) which was created and disappeared in the 1960s.  Once its existence was known in Nuku'alofa the then Prince Tungi (later King George Tupou III, and the present king's father) despatched a boat to the "island" and planted the Tongan flag.  

Whether he was similarly motivated in having a beacon built on Minerva only he could say, but it does seem to me that, if ownership is in dispute, friendly proper practice would have been to discuss the matter with Fiji  before going ahead with its construction. Instead, as we know, the beacon was built and later it was destroyed by Fiji, which was not a friendly gesture, either.

Had there been a beacon on the reef in the 1962 a Tongan boat, the Tuaekaepau, would not have been wrecked there on its way to Gisborne in NZ, and its 17 crew would not have been marooned for 102 days, where they were given up for dead and some died. Realized that they were assumed dead and could not expect rescue, and knowing that if they stayed much longer on the reef all would die, they built a crude outrigger canoe, the Malo e lelei, from wood found in the wrecked Japanese fishing boat in which they lived, and Captain Tevita Fifita, his son and another crew member sailed for help. Blown off course close to Kadavu, 570 kilometres to the north, they abandoned the outrigger and swam over the reef. The son was totally exhausted, and his father nearly so. They held on to each other, prayed and then the son drowned.

Along with most of the population of Tongatapu I was on Faua Wharf when the RNZAF Sunderland Flying Boat from Fiji brought the survivors home. It was one of the most moving moments in my life.

In old Polynesian custom occupance and shedding blood or dying in a place gave one some claim to ownership but I doubt those incredible 102 days will stengthen Tonga's claim. If you want to know more, I highly recommend Olaf Ruhen's "Minerva Reef."

'At Swim, 3 Birds' (with apologies to Flann O'Brien) by Balor
An Oceanian Fantasy involving the emu, kiwi and frigate-bird: fleet, flightless and in-flight.

A leader bird lowers the moral bar.
Fast, ostrich-like, big feet, feathers unruffled.
Her china in F.A. limbos under it effortlessly
Like the inscrutable pro he is.
Friendly Islands' visitor in distress glides down under too.
No lyre-bird, he. No parrot surely? Warbler perhaps? Let other blow-ins judge.
Besides, the little kiwi -key player in it all- saves face.
So, dear asylum seekers to Gondwanaland, you huddled masses,
Sail straight on by to southern Lau or Tonga
For immediate immigration processing.


Mal said…
There is a small Fijian island that is actually closer to Minerva than Ata island.The difference is small but it exists.
Ono i Lau is also closer than Tongatapu as being the nearest occupied islands of the respective countries.
Minerva Madness! said…
While this unseemly and ridiculous dispute acts as a displacement activity, there are eight women who are known to die soon from a totally curable disease: cervical cancer. They are all young and some of them have more than one child. This nonsensical spat about a spit of land which is covered by the sea some of the time, is a demonstration of callous stupidity in the face of real and pressing matters:

Why are Fiji women still dying of cervical cancer untreated, uncared for by modern methods of diagnosis and treatment? This was so in 1976 when Professor Christopher Sutton of Cambridge University went public about it before leaving this country. He is now one of the UK's top five Obstestricians and Gynaecologists.

It is STILL so, thanks to nonsense like the MINERVA REEF!
Anonymous said…
Ian Simpson Taveuni
@ Mal said..

In addition if one googlearths one will see two distinct undersea ridges that run up from North Island New Zealand all the way up to both island groups.
The Minerva reef is part of the chain of islands called Lau and memory serves me right, I think this ridge is in fact called the Lau Ridge.

Some live on continetal shelves islanders live on sea ridges.
Gutter press said…
Ian and Mal
If we manage to claim Minerva reef by virtue of Fiji's closest island being closer to it than Tonga's closest island then once we've got Minerva we'll be able to claim Raoul - which will then be about 300km closer to Fiji than to NZ. Then we'll be able to claim Macauley and Cheeseman. We'll be on the steps of parliament house in Wellington before you know it.

Minerva Madness! - my vote's with you. The thousands of our taxpayer dollars spent on the appallingly stupid journey to destroy a beacon would have been far better spent on health care and education.

Popular posts from this blog

Fijian Holdings Scandal: Betrayal by their trusted sons

Lessons from Africa

The Ratu Tevita Saga, Coup4.5, Michael Field, the ANU Duo, and Tonga